Subject: Re: Who is a Jew
Date: Thu, 10 Aug 2000 23:32:11 -0500
From: purnhrt <email@example.com>
To: Michael Detwiler <firstname.lastname@example.org>, email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org,
Michael, James just sent a note, "At this point "legal phase" means that I
have spoken with my attorney and am contemplating legal remedies. It doe not
mean that I have filed a suit at this point." So why is it that if he was
just inquiring, you chose to use that as a means of not answering a valid
question, concerning the Beit Din? And why did you send it to me and not
Since when is it harassment to ask the questions that others
concerning your operation of the Beit Din. It seems to me that you dont want
to answer, not that you can't answer. Perhaps if enough people are made aware
of the question and are asking it themselves, then perhaps you might give an
accountability of what exactly is going on over there. It would seem that if
you men met the standards that you devised, you would have no problem with my
questions and could very easily answer them and any others.
The question is very simple Michael, what has this Beit
Din established for
their acceptance of who is Jew by birth, for voting purposes? And please be
specific. Shalom, Kathryn
Michael Detwiler wrote:
> There is no shalom here. This is feeding your yetzer
hara. We do not
> submit to your questioning, nor do we intend to subject ourselves to your
> harassment and continued abuse.
> This has moved to a legal phase, therefore, there cannot be communication.
> At 01:47 PM 8/9/00 -0500, you wrote:
> >SHalom b'YHWH
> >To the members of the Beit Din. I am writing to ask what the Beit Din
> >determines a Jew to be, from birth. Please be specific. For example, do
> >you consider a Jew from birth to be a person whose mother was a Jew, or
> >do you consider a person whose father was a Jew to be one, or both? Do
> >you consider a person who had one grandparent on one side or both to be
> >Jewish, or must it be a maternal grandmother? Shalom, Kathryn
> >YHWH bless you and guard you. YHWH make His face to shine upon you and
> >show you favor. YHWH lift up His face upon you and give you shalom.
YHWH bless you and guard you. YHWH make His face to shine upon you and show
you favor. YHWH lift up His face upon you and give you shalom.